It’s interesting how the publicity side of films wants to rule what people think. As well they should, that’s their job.
After leaving screenings of The Departed and Infamous, the p.r. person (a contract job proffered by a public relations firm hired by a film studio) specifically asked me A) in the case of Departed what I thought about its Oscar chances, and B) regarding Infamous, how I thought it compared to Capote.
It was easy to answer the former query. Ask somebody in the Academy, I snapped back to the loaded question. When the Academy picks its five nominees I will tell you the one I think will win. If this is any indication of the ramp-up of prognostication to come, prepare yourself for the biggest Oscar media shitstorm ever.
As for Infamous, which covers much of the same ground as last year’s Capote, the real question should be how does it stack up against the films that are coming out at the same time: films as diverse as Flags of Our Fathers, Marie Antoinette, The Prestige, not to mention the plethora of October horror flicks with numbers in the title. Saw III or Grudge 2 anyone? As for comedies you can write those off to the DVD rental in two months category. Employee of the Month was not funny, and worse to sit through than School for Scoundrels, which also was not funny. How sad is it that you have to reach back to the also not funny You, Me and Dupree just to recall a film that at least allowed one to crack a smile.
The truth is a little Truman Capote goes a long way. There was a Capote comedy skit back in the 1970s where the National Lampoon Comedy Hour had a Truman soundalike explaining how “My father stuck me in a closet with a bowling ball bag over my head.” In Infamous the soundalike, Toby Jones, is also a dead ringer for the real Capote. Jones most notably plays the voice of Dobby the Elf in the Harry Potter series. Perhaps the portrayal of Capote will become the new trial by fire of contemporary actors. Philip Seymour Hoffman won an Oscar for his Capote turn, but physically Hoffman is anything but diminutive and squeaky voiced.
As similar as Infamous is to Capote in terms of plot (famous writer travels to the scene of a brutal murder in Middle America to re-invent the novel) the directorial hands are wide apart. Infamous helmer Douglas McGrath delivers a first act frothy with wit. But by the end the film has spiraled into a grim drama, with an intense near-rape scene between Jones and Daniel Craig (next month’s blue-eyed James Bond). Craig plays Perry Smith with a rage as black as his contact lenses.
If Infamous is a double with the runner sliding in safe, then Martin Scorsese’s The Departed is a home run in the upper seats.
Dense in cinematic layers – occasional brilliant acting riffs, complicated plot with plenty of double crosses, expert use of rock songs to accent violence and character – the main thing I felt coming out of The Departed was how I longed to see it a second time.
Scorsese’s direction feels like a tuned racing engine firing on all cylinders. Sure, Scorsese’s in his element with a crime film. But Scorsese goes beyond recycling Goodfellas cheer and adds taunt suspense to Departed’s truly stunning ending. Not that the film lacks violence. Early on, we see Leonardo DiCaprio mopping up a convenience store with some thugs, and as he’s turning this guy’s face into pulp the soundtrack launches into “Land of a 1000 Dances.” It’s Scorsese reminding us that, yes, he’s seen Kill Bill Vol.1 where the same musical cue left a mark.
With Scorsese’s master touch the film is sculpted to feel like an hour even though the action takes two-and-a-half hours.
It didn’t start out as a Gwyneth Paltrow double feature but there you have it – I saw Infamous and Running With Scissors on the same day - both films where Paltrow plays a supporting role. She only appears briefly in Infamous, as a lounge singer in the opening scene. The song waivers as the blonde siren experiences a moment where you think she might collapse in the middle of her warble.
Running With Scissors, set in the groovy late 1970s, places Paltrow with an ensemble that includes Jill Clayburgh, Evan Rachel Wood, Joseph Fiennes as members of an unorthodox psychiatrist’s family. Paltrow, while only in a couple of scenes, has a psycho thousand-yard stare that will chill the uninitiated. Annette Benning, Brian Cox and Joseph Cross trade off leading roles as the story switches between Cox’s insurance fraud, Benning’s medicated stupor, with Cross (playing author Augusten Burroughs) experiencing the entire farce while going through puberty.